Monday, August 3, 2009

LAST PROPHET OF SECULARISM

Even as the national media collectively orgasmed over Rakhi Sawant’s engagement this past weekend, a colossus passed away in Kerala. More than a million people braved the rains to pay homage to Panakkad Mohammadali Shihab Thangal, the President of the Indian Union Muslim League.

For the devout, Shihab Thangal was the descendant of the Prophet himself. For the politically attuned, he was the most influential Muslim political leader in Kerala. Not the rabid, chest-thumping, victim playing, regressive kind. But one who was fiercely secular and progressive in spite of the gravest odds.

For more than three decades, Shihab Thangal was the cornerstone of coalition politics in God’s Own Country. The rudder, without whom, the experiment called UDF would never have seen the light of day. For a man who never contested an election and who never held any governmental / constitutional post, Shihab Thangal wielded unparalleled clout. His was the last word for a large majority of the Muslims of North Kerala.

The man was avowedly secular, down to his bone marrow. Imagine a Muslim leader saying this, just days after the Babri Masjid demolition in 1992. “Not one stone will be thrown at a Hindu house. In fact, every Muslim will stand guard at his Hindu brethren’s house.” It takes a man of extreme conviction or plain balls to say that. If God’s own country didn’t flare up after the infamous events of 6 Dec 92, then God has this steadfast disciple to thank. In the face of the gravest provocation, Shihab Thangal did not dilute his own or the League’s fierce secularism. And in hindsight, he was proven right.

But political clout alone doesn’t explain the phenomenon that Shihab Thangal was. He was also a supreme religious head. For the believers of the Word, he was a descendant of the Holy Prophet himself. He was also a great philanthropic. Someone who realized that the truest disciples of Allah are the ones who take care of their brethren.

There’s a fascinating story about the poor people who used to visit Thangal’s ancestral home, Kurappanakkal in Panakkad village. Thangal used to ensure that each one of them was given one proper meal and return bus fares. For him, charity was not a service, it was a solemn duty. Something which every prosperous Muslim owed to his Creator for the blessings he was bestowed with.

What makes his story even more fascinating is when you compare him with other Muslim leaders of his time, in the rest of India. Not one of them can even hold a candle to kind of contributions Shihab Thangal has done for the Muslims of Malappuram. Malappuram wasn’t exactly the most prosperous district in Kerala. In the sixties and seventies, it ranked fairly low in almost all major social indices. Today, Malappuram is India’s first e-literate district. And Shihab Thangal has had no small role to play in this.

Compare this to the Maulvis and Ulemas in UP and Bihar. They have a vested interest in keeping a majority of their community poor and backward. Else, the political relevance of these reverend men diminishes. Agreed that over time, various political parties have treated Muslims as a monolithic vote bank. But Muslim leaders will have to share some of that blame as well. After all you can’t keep playing the victim card all the time.

As the Muslims of Kerala mourn the passing away of one of their favourite sons, let’s also redeem our faith in all that Shihab Thangal stood for. Compassion, humility and decency. He was truly the last prophet of secularism.

Sunday, August 2, 2009

UNDERSTANDING BALOCHISTAN, FROM A PAK PERSPECTIVE

Ever since the PM returned from Sharm El-Sheikh, he’s been pilloried for that ill-fated joint statement. More than the D word, it’s the B word, which has got many hawkish analysts fuming. How could the PM have allowed a reference to Balochistan? Doesn’t this indirectly put both India and Pakistan on an even keel, with both equally guilty of sponsoring terror?

Now this is not an attempt to defend the Prime Minister, but just to look at Balochistan, from a Pakistani perspective. To understand why our neighbours are paranoid about a swathe of wasteland, which many in Pakistan themselves call "the dump where Allah shot the rubbish of creation."

Balochistan is critical for Pakistan. Balochistan is to Pakistan what Xinjiang is for China. It’s the jewel in Pakistan’s crown. There are two very simple reasons for this. One, that it has tremendous reserves of natural gas which is critical to Pakistan’s energy needs. Just over the last month or so, there have been bloody riots in Pakistan over the lack of electricity. Delhi’s power woes would seem like a dream when compared to the blackhole ordinary Pakistanis have been putting up with, day after day. Chambers of Commerce estimate Pakistan lost as much as a billion dollars in exports last fiscal, due to power cuts. Its manufacturing has fallen by 8 percent. Even Richard Holbrooke, in his visit there last week, had to pepper his praise for the Pak Army’s fight against the Taliban with the crucial need to tackle power cuts. That’s why Balochistan is critical for Pakistan’s future energy needs. Two important pipelines, one from Turkmenistan and the other from Iran pass through this region. This gas will not reach power generation stations in Karachi and Lahore, if Balochi nationals keep bombing the pipelines which carry them, every other day.

The second reason is that Balochistan, because of its arid terrain and vast swathes of rocky wasteland provides crucial buffer against any invading force. Already India is slowly but surely encircling Pakistan. Now India can attack Pakistan, not just from its eastern flank. We’ve got strategic depth in Afghanistan, in the west. An air force base in Tajikistan, in the north, from where we can fly fighter jets to bombard Pakistan. And reputed American scholars have admitted that the Indian consulate in the east Iranian city of Zehdan is doing more than just issuing visas. India is even engaged in building a world class port in the city of Chahbar in South East Iran. It’s India’s answer to what the Chinese have been doing in Gwadar.

The Pakistanis, and this is not just the military-intelligence establishment, are paranoid about India’s growing leverage in Afghanistan. They’re mortally scared of the day, the favourite benefactor of the Pakistani state and the country which ordinary Pakistanis love to hate, America, withdraws from Afghanistan.

And India hasn’t exactly helped in quelling this paranoia. We’ve been cultivating strategic depth in Afghanistan for a while now. India says we have only 9 consulates in Afghanistan. (That’s more than what we have in the US and UK, by the way). The Pakistanis say we have about 22. In the world of covert intelligence, where nothing can be the absolute truth, I am prepared to believe that the actual number is somewhere in between. From Pakistan’s point of view, you have a neighbour who you’re perennially suspicious of in the eastern flank, with unprecedented clout in your western flank. Naturally any country would be paranoid. That’s just what the Pakistanis are going through.

By agreeing to put Balochistan in the joint statement, Manmohan Singh is directly addressing the intelligence communities on both sides. And this is where the media seemed to have missed the tree for the woods. For the Indian intelligence establishment, this is a wake up call. A clear message from the Prime Minister that you can’t go on forever without any form of accountability. After all, the intelligence community, because of the very nature it’s DNA, is perennially suspicious of peace. They are the first ones to raise the red flag to any peace overtures.

And to the Pakistani intelligence establishment, who are most paranoid about Balochistan, Dr. Singh’s message is clear. Look, we’re willing to talk about your worst fears. And we’re not going to shy away from it. We’re willing to talk about it, like civilized nations. Now it’s upto you to show the same earnestness in addressing what you’re doing in Kashmir and other parts of India. He has directly addressed General Kayani and his gang, the so-called real power centre of Pakistan. It’s upto them to meet us half-way.

In the near-term Dr. Singh is getting plastered for allowing the B-word to slip in. But in the long term, it’s Gilani who needs to be worried. Because, unwittingly now, Balochistan has been internationalized. The spotlight of the international community will start falling on this piece of land, which until now, the Pakistanis have been deliberately loath to discuss about. What happened to Kashmir in 1948, is now happening to Balochistan, sixty years later. It may not seem so on the face of it, but there’s a method to the Sardar’s madness.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

IN THE PM'S DEFENCE

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has had a torrid couple of weeks. Ever since he inked that ill-fated joint statement in Sharm El-Sheikh, Manmohan Singh has been shredded to bits. By the opposition, by the media and worse, by his own partymen. It’s almost as if the genial Sardar has bartered away India’s sovereignty. That all honour and pride were sacrificed, because Pakistan got away with two phrases more.

For far too long, our foreign policy has been guided by narrow mindedness and petty point scoring. It doesn’t really matter where the commas and full stops are in a joint statement. Nor does it matter if India won the Yekaterinburg round and Pakistan made it even stevens with Sharm El Sheikh.

Little men are guided by timidity. Great nations thrive on courage. India is a country standing at the cusp of greatness. We cannot afford to be seen as timid and petty. We need to look at the larger picture. And the larger picture is that India needs to take the initiative in being the dominant player in South Asia. For which we need to ensure a stable South Asia. And that cannot happen if India and Pakistan, the region’s two biggest nations, behave like adolescent fighter-cocks, always at each other’s throats. It can only be achieved by sitting down and talking, through civilized dialogue. We need to think big, think bold.

That’s what Lincoln did. That’s what Gandhi did. And the world remembers them for precisely that. Because in their most difficult moments, they did not shy away. They didn’t buckle. They did not settle for less. India cannot settle for less.

Look at Barack Obama. Here’s a man who’s willing to talk to a country like Iran. A country, which just a few years ago, his predecessor had bracketed in the ‘Axis of Evil’. Today, Obama is not just willing to talk to Iran, he’s even done something that no US President has ever had the spinal cord to do. Apologize for past ills which the US has inflicted on the Muslim world. Because Obama realizes that history cannot bind you from moving ahead. History cannot hinder you from charting a new course. Manmohan Singh knows this too. He knows that India’s path to greatness will only clear if we resolve our disputes with our neighbours. And our dispute with Pakistan tops that list.

Look at China. President Hu Jintao has sorted out every land dispute China has had with its neighbours, (and there are more than 15 of them) save the one with India. Forget about ASEAN and Shanghai Co-operation, where China is the most dominant player already, today there’s talk of a G2. Just China and the United States. India, at the same time, is still stuck in the diplomacy of the seventies.

By de-linking terror and talks, the PM has only done the most sensible thing. That is to not hold the composite dialogue hostage to each and every terrorist attack. It was almost like an on-off button. Every time there was a terror strike, the first casualty would be the dialogue process. Not that suspending the dialogue every time decreased terrorism directed against India. It’s not like we had great leverage with Pakistan in the first place, just because terror and talks were linked.

After the Mumbai attacks, India received a lot of sympathy. And we have used that to the hilt to squeeze Pakistan as much as we can. But there’s only so much sympathy can buy. You can’t keep playing victim all the time. Coercive diplomacy comes with a use-by-date. Civilized nations talk. And that’s all India and Pakistan agreed to do, in Sharm El-Sheikh.

The other big brouhaha was created over the reference to Balochistan. The Leader of the Opposition says, this will haunt us for the rest of time. I don’t know what we’re so afraid of. Great nations don’t run away from the truth, however uncomfortable it may be. They confront it. All that the PM has said is this, “Ok Mr. Gilani, I understand your concerns on Balochistan. Give me evidence of Indian involvement and we are prepared to talk about it.” That doesn’t mean we have readily admitted that we’re fawning terror in Balochistan.

The onus now is on the Pakistanis to prove that India is interfering in Balochistan. And trust me, in the world of covert intelligence these things are as hard to prove as walking on water. Manmohan Singh is a sensible man. He’s not the type who’ll play darts blindfolded.

Yes, agreed there are vested interests in Pakistan that don’t want us to talk. Just like there are vested interests in India which don’t want us to talk. The Army and intelligence establishment in Pakistan are only interested in fanning passions between India and Pakistan. It’s critical to their existence. We need to fight those vested interests. The same interests which are inimical to Pakistan are inimical to India too. The Good Doctor understands this. He wants to break away from 62 years of low trickery and petty pin-pricks. For once, let us give him the benefit of doubt.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

WALTER CRONKITE (1916 - 2009). R.I.P.

Walter Cronkite, the voice of TV news is dead. Thus, screamed New York Times’ lead headline, Saturday morning. It was one of those moments. When you know that the world will be worse off. When you know that an institution had passed away.

When I came to work that afternoon, I asked around in the newsroom on how many people knew of a man named Walter Cronkite. Sadly, but as expected, not many did. A man, who for an entire generation was the only source of news, was today an unknown entity for the Youtube generation.

Yet Cronkite is as relevant today as ever before. In these times of shrill, high pitched reporting and opinionators masquerading as news anchors, Cronkite is the man to turn to. He was the man who America turned to every evening to know what was happening in the world around them. And this relationship between Cronkite and America was built on one fundamental quality. Trust.

No wonder, in 1995, 14 years after he retired from the Evening News, Walter Cronkite was America’s most trusted man. More than even President Clinton, who at that time was at the peak of his powers.

He became something of a national institution. Cronkite’s presence was reassuring. America trusted him with the news, whether good or bad. And for his part Cronkite too stuck to the news. He didn’t need to pilfer news with his own opinion or spiel to make it sound ‘sexy’. He told the news, just the way it was.

“I am a news presenter, a news broadcaster, an anchorman, a managing editor — not a commentator or analyst,” he said in an interview with The Christian Science Monitor. “I feel no compulsion to be a pundit.” He rarely pronounced judgment.

News TV, both in the States and here in India has a lot to learn from Uncle Walter. News television today has been reduced to slam-bang talkathons. It’s so darn predictable. If it’s a political issue, get a Congress guy and a BJP guy. Get both of them to have a go at each other. In between, anchors evangelize their two bits.

And there’s a very simple reason why news TV has been reduced to this dirty theatre. Talk is cheap and talk sells. Talk is also entertaining and lazy. Therefore, there’s so much talk in the news. Anchoring in news TV has been reduced to hectoring and finger-wagging. And often times, I myself, have been guilty of this.

And so as I mourn the loss of such an invaluable soul, let me also solemnly reaffirm my pledge to all that Walter Cronkite stood for. Fairness, objectivity and the pursuit of truth. And that’s the way it is.

Monday, July 13, 2009

THE CURIOUS CASE OF COMRADE VS

In the legions of Communist struggles, the one revolt which is always cited in almost ‘halo’ey terms is the Punnapra Vayalar agitation of 1946. Almost a 1000 Communist party workers fought a bloody battle with the police on the picturesque beaches of Punnapra. Among them was a young 22 year old, coir factory worker. Velikkakathu Sankaran Achuthanandan. It was the first anti-burgeois battle that he fought. Over the years, he has fought a thousand more.

Today VS Achuthanandan or Comrade VS as he’s fondly called is one of the stalwarts of the Communist movement in Kerala. He’s also an isolated man. His party, the CPI(M), of which he is one of the founding fathers, has decided to dump him. The oldest member of the party’s highest decision making body, the Politburo, no longer has a place in this esteemed club. He has been ‘disciplined’, almost as if VS were a 22 year old rebel. You don’t ‘discipline’ an 83 year old veteran.

When VS along with fellow comrades blew up the Mayithara bridge in Mararikulam, his hometown, it was one of the most fervent challenges to the then Dewan of Travancore, the legendary Sir CP Ramaswamy Aiyar. Prakash Karat wasn’t even born then. Today, 61 year old Karat, guided by pelfs and pimps, has decided to dump the 83 year old VS.

Not that VS is not used to such ham-handed behaviour by the high command. The legendary EMS had censured VS because he offered to donate blood to Indian soldiers in the Indo-China war of 1962. For the Comrades, defying China was sacrilege.

VS’ luck has been awful at times. If he had his way, he should’ve been Chief Minister back in 1996. The party had won a decisive victory. VS was the state secretary and the man tipped for the top job. Unfortunately he lost from his hometown of Mararikulam, for the first time since 1967. He was done in by his own detractors within the party. VS had to make way for EK Nayanar. Five years later he won a handsome victory from Malampuzha. His party though bit the dust.

For the next five years, as Leader of the Opposition, he was at the helm of every major people’s agitation. From Muthanga to Plachimada to Idukki, if there was a people’s cause, VS was always there at the forefront. Come the next election in 2006, he was the most eligible claimant for the Chief Minister’s chair. Unfortunately his party let him down once again.

Once again Prakash Karat, guided by power mongerers decided not to give a ticket to VS. There was a people’s revolt. Something the Communists had never witnessed before. At virtually every street corner, a VS cutout or a VS poster sprang up. The iron-fisted theorists sitting in AKG Bhavan were hit by a tsunami of people’s power. For the first time, the Polit Buro had to reverse a decision, under popular pressure. VS got a ticket. The LDF won and VS became Chief Minister.

But the same sharks and savagers wouldn’t let go. For three years and some months now, they’ve made life hell for VS. He was Chief Minister only on paper. The real power lay in the corridors of AKG Bhavan, both in Delhi and Trivandrum. At every possible instance, VS was cut down to size. And last week’s decision to drop him from the Polit Buro was the final cut. The unkindest of all.

VS now has only two options. One, to succumb to the party high command and accept it’s decision meekly. The other, to revolt and walk out of the party. Which one will 83 year old, angry young man choose?

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

CHURCH IN YOUR PANTS?

I am a practicing Christian. And I am proud of it. I am also a supporter of equal rights for gays and lesbians. And I am equally proud of it. And I don’t see a contradiction between the two.

First, nowhere in the Bible is there any record, no direct quote from Jesus Christ about homosexuality. Either condemning it or condoning it. Not one word. The other important thing to note is that nowhere in the Bible does it say anything about homosexuality as a sexual orientation. It only refers to certain homosexual acts.

And these acts/events/incidents are interpreted by different people at different points in history. But interpretations are always defined by time, place and societal context. And interpretations change with the afore-mentioned variables. Just a couple of quick examples. There are portions in the Bible which view slavery and slave trade as a legitimate activity. Not anymore. Again, in the Old Testament, deliberately withdrawing before ejaculation was equated to abortion. Not anymore. The church has evolved with the times. Things that were taboo are norm nowadays.

At the heart of this debate is viewing homosexuality as a sexual orientation. You can no more deplore homosexuality than you can condemn left-handedness. It’s not a disease. It’s just the way some people are. That’s it. Homosexual affection can be as selfless as heterosexual affection. Gay persons desire and need deep and lasting relationships, just like heterosexuals do. They too are human after all. The Bible only mentions “Love your neighbour as you love thyself.” It doesn’t mention the neighbour’s gender.

The Catholic Church in India has blindly taken this position because Vatican has decreed so. But that’s where the problem lies. In India, the gay rights debate has little to do with whether God is accepting of homosexuals or not. Whether it is anti-Christian or not. It’s about an archaic, asinine law called Section 377. A colonial relic which we should’ve junked along with the British. Instead it continues to discriminate against and criminalize millions of gay and lesbian men and women. Why? Are they the children of a lesser God? Were they not also created by the same God, who created you and me? By opposing homosexuality, the Church is also uncannily supporting this ridiculous law. It’s the only issue on which the Church, the Jamaat e Islami and the VHP are on the same side. Not the kind of company, the Church would like to keep.

This is an appeal to the various denominations in India to come clean on this issue. Supporting homosexuals in their fight for civil rights is equivalent to supporting Dalits in their fight against the caste system. Christianity is pillared on the fundamental of social justice. Everyone is equal in the eyes of God. At its root, this problem is about equality. It’s not as much about ‘them’, as it is about all of us.

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

NAXALS ARE NOT TERRORISTS, MR. CHIDAMBARAM

The ability of governments to score self-goals is just phenomenal. The UPA government has done just that by banning Naxal group CPI (Maoist). By equating Naxals with terrorist outfits like Lashkar and HuJI, the government has once again missed the tree for the woods.

Before we get to anything else, let’s get this one simple fact straight. Naxalism is not born out of the flawed interpretation of some religion. Naxalism is born out of hunger. Out of poverty. Out of extreme social and economic deprivation. Naxlism breeds precisely because Mr. Chidambaram and his institutions cannot provide vast swathes of our poor people three square meals a day and a decent life. That’s why poor, famished people who have no other resort, take to the loud bang of a gun. To make a deaf government hear their voice.

WHAT ABOUT STATE SPONSORED TERROR?

It’s funny how when any poor man raises a gun against the state it’s termed as terrorism. But when the state itself raises a gun against its own people, it’s called patriotism. What about extra judicial killings? What about custodial deaths? Doesn’t this amount to terrorism as well? Transparency International says, every year around the world more people fall victim to state sponsored terrorism than to terrorism per se.

DISPROPORTIONATE USE OF FORCE

Just look at the number of troops fighting the naxals. There are 26 battalions, that’s 26,000 men of the Central Paramilitary Forces alone who are dedicated to fighting Naxals. In addition you now have the elite anti-naxal COBRA force which makes up for another 11,000. Apart from this, state governments themselves have special anti-naxal forces. The greyhounds in Andhra Pradesh number about 18,000. Jharkhand has a special force of about 14,000. In all, if you look at the entire red corridor, there are about half a million security men taking on a motley army of Maoists. And has anyone bothered to check the number of Maoists. Deprived men and women whom, the Prime Minister calls India’s enemy number one. All over the country, the cadres strength of the Maoists is just 10,500. If this is not an unequal war, then what is?

And after all this, the number of violent incidents attributed to Maoists has been reported only in 4% of the police stations across India.

WHY A BAN IS FUTILE

The Government had earlier banned the previous avatar of the CPI Maoists, the People’s War Group (PWG). Not that the Maoist movement simply withered away. It assumed a new name and a new form. Bans per se amount to squat. If the government is serious about tackling the Naxal menace, it has to review the way it perceives Naxalism. It’s not just a black and white law and order menace. It has to be treated as a socio-economic problem. These are our own people who are begging for their voices to be heard. But the question is: Is a Van Heusen clad Home Minister listening?